DT Deep Dive

***2023 Week 5 Results***

With Week 4 behind us, let's look back and see how the rankings performed with details on each metric and last season's results available here:

A little up and down this week with many of the expected top performers underperforming and some of the deeper recommendations putting up solid numbers. Overall, Week 5 tied season highs in terms of Solid Tier players over 10 and 20 pts and massive hit rate across all recommended plays and lows in terms of Ideal Tier average and players over 20 pts. Also, none of the 45 recommended plays put up a 0 so I'm very happy about that for all of our sake! 

PERFORMANCE BY TIER

Tier 3 continues to outperformed expectations with another strong performance by Tiers 2 and lackluster output by Tier 1. Still, there remains a sizeable gap between the top 3 tiers and the bottom tier. 

ACCURACY AGAINST PROJECTIONS

Very happy with this week's results. Biggest boom rate of the season, no whiffs (0s), and a modified hit rate* close to 65%.

*Modified hit rate counts players who missed projection by less than 1 assisted tackle.

FANTASY PROS ACCURACY

It is still hard to predict the top scorers week to week but I am buoyed by the fact that I am hanging in there or even squeaking out a lead against MFL's projected top scorers and the rankings of "Expert X".

***2023 Week 5 Rankings***

Welcome to the Week 5 edition of the DT Deep Dive! Apologies for running a day late but my family and I were traveling Mon-Wed which threw everything off! 

For the season, the model is performing very well after some small tweaks as the season has worn on (more on those changes below). Average scoring, startable players, hits, and misses mostly follow expectations along tiers (Tier 2 has been overperforming expectations a bit). Recommended plays across all tiers are outperforming projections nearly 60% of the time with a 28% massive hit rate. If I give myself the same grace as others and call recommendations who scored within an assist of their projection "Accurate*", my accuracy rate jumps to 68.6%. Finally, the top end of my ratings are still outperforming  both "Expert X" and FantasySharks across 2 of 3 accuracy measures (average and % correct) with progress made last week to close the FantasyPros-style metric. Full 2023 season and weekly results available here.

Moving into Week 5, I have dug into the data a bit to model some new variables such as PFF's measure of opponent offensive line quality (not just pressure rates) and PFF's measure of overall team offense (alongside pace of play) to try to estimate team defensive snap counts. I have also added a negative value for the top performing O-Lines in the league. These remain much smaller values than those placed on snap shares, pass rush grades, and run defense grades (in that order). More analyses of all these metrics coming soon!

Come back over the weekend for some commentary on selected players but in the interest of getting this out before TNF...let's get to the players!

Ideal Tier is guys you would start in any format (and even consider in DL leagues that don't explicitly require DT).

Solid Tier is players are also expected to perform well and you can usually start to find some potential streamers in this group.

Solid (Deeper) Tier is mostly going to be relevant in 16 team leagues, leagues where you have to start 2 DT, or leagues with very deep benches.

Avoid Tier is mostly players who did not have strong enough snap counts in Week 1 to warrant consideration in leagues other than Best Ball that you are managing in-season.

Good luck!

Week 5 DT Streamers (outside the top 30 rostered on MFL)

Week 4 - David Onyemata (30.95) and Arik Armstead (5.75), Season-long average at 14.76.

David Onyemata, ATL

Count me among those who do not think his DT2 overall performance last week was a fluke! Onyemata is still criminally under-rostered despite great PFF grades and snap shares.

DaQuon Jones, BUF

Jones' grades are too good to ignore at this point and while a snap share in the 50s is less than ideal, you could do much worse for streaming options.

Week 5 DT Rankings

Disclaimer 1: My model is performing well, but don't take these as gospel. Sometimes I even start a lower ranked guy who is more proven if the rest of my roster is in a place where I need to be risk averse (especially this early in the season).

Disclaimer 2: Check for guys who are out. There may even be 1-2 ranked guys on IR if they had enough snaps this year. I'll catch some of these when doing data entry but not all.

Here is the full list of 113 DTs rated this week (I pruned out players with snap numbers that did not allow for reliable assessment of performance). Note - tiers are sorted so higher in tier = better.


TIER 1 - IDEAL

Chris Jones KC

Dexter Lawrence II NYG

David Onyemata ATL

Aaron Donald LA

Derrick Brown CAR

Daron Payne WAS

Quinnen Williams NYJ

Jeffery Simmons TEN


TIER 2 - SOLID

Jonathan Allen WAS

Javon Hargrave SF

Harrison Phillips MIN

Zach Allen DEN

Christian Wilkins MIA

Fletcher Cox PHI

DaQuan Jones BUF

Kenny Clark GB

Denico Autry TEN

John Jenkins LV


TIER 3 - SOLID (DEEPER LEAGUES)

Grady Jarrett ATL

Zach Sieler MIA

Byron Young LV

Arik Armstead SF

Shy Tuttle CAR

Ed Oliver BUF

D.J. Jones DEN

T.J. Slaton GB

Roy Robertson-Harris JAX

Larry Ogunjobi PIT

Justin Jones CHI

Alim McNeill DET

Kobie Turner LA

Leki Fotu ARZ

Andrew Billings CHI

Khalen Saunders NO

Christian Barmore NE

Leonard Williams NYG

Jalen Carter PHI

Jonathan Ledbetter ARZ

Maliek Collins HST

Quinton Jefferson NYJ

D.J. Reader CIN

John Cominsky DET

Nathan Shepherd NO

B.J. Hill CIN

Jonathan Harris DEN

Adam Butler LV

Grover Stewart IND


TIER 4 - AVOID

Michael Pierce BLT

Osa Odighizuwa DAL

Jonah Williams LA

Devonte Wyatt GB

Teair Tart TEN

Kevin Strong ARZ

Travis Jones BLT

DeForest Buckner IND

Justin Madubuike BLT

Broderick Washington BLT

Javon Kinlaw SF

Dante Stills ARZ

Chauncey Golston DAL

Keeanu Benton PIT

Montravius Adams PIT

Sheldon Rankins HST

Kurt Hinish HST

Solomon Thomas NYJ

Jordan Davis PHI

Taven Bryan IND

Eric Johnson IND

Bryan Bresee NO

Kevin Givens SF

Mike Purcell DEN

Keion White NE

Karl Brooks GB

Jonathan Bullard MIN

Milton Williams PHI

Gervon Dexter Sr. CHI

Zacch Pickens CHI

Malcolm Roach NO

Derrick Nnadi KC

DeShawn Williams CAR

Neville Gallimore DAL

Mazi Smith DAL

Johnathan Hankins DAL

Bobby Brown III LA

Matt Henningsen DEN

Colby Wooden GB

Tim Settle BUF

Kyle Peko TEN

Jerry Tillery LV

Folorunso Fatukasi JAX

Josh Tupou CIN

Zach Carter CIN

Dean Lowry MIN

Raekwon Davis MIA

Benito Jones DET

Tershawn Wharton KC

Matt Dickerson KC

Nick Thurman CAR

John Ridgeway WAS

Davon Godchaux NE

Lawrence Guy Sr. NE

A'Shawn Robinson NYG

Rakeem Nunez-Roches NYG

Jordan Phillips BUF

Bilal Nichols LV

Adam Gotsis JAX

Angelo Blackson JAX

Jeremiah Ledbetter JAX

Armon Watts PIT

DeMarvin Leal PIT

Isaiahh Loudermilk PIT

Ta'Quon Graham ATL

Al Woods NYJ